Past research revealed that a neighborhood's
crime level is linked to its social composition. In chapter 7 – The Theory of
Collective Efficacy Sampson defines “collective efficacy” as mutual trust among
neighbors combined with willingness to intervene on behalf of the common good. Collective
efficacy theory goes further to argue that repeated interactions, observations
of interactions, and an awareness of potential interactions that could be
invoked all establish shared norms (a sense of we) beyond the strong ties among
friends and kin (Sampson, 153). Further, he suggests that the largest single
predictor of crime levels in the neighborhoods was "collective efficacy."
Sampson finding challenges the widely accepted view of crime resulting from
factors such as poverty and unemployment. As with individual efficacy,
collective efficacy is partly “endogenous” or contingent on the challenges at
hand, cultural contexts, and the stratification of places by key structural
characteristics (Sampson 154). The study, limited to Chicago’s neighborhoods,
revealed that neighborhoods scoring high on collective efficacy, have crime
rates far below neighborhoods with lower scores. Also, neighborhoods with
strong residential stability also tended to have strong collective efficacy.
According to Sampson collective efficacy theory
has been tested in cities in the United States as well as in Stockholm, Sweden
only. That raises the question how generalizable the results of these studies
are to cities with different macro-level conditions. For example, I have found
a very interesting paper, “The Limits of Collective Efficacy: Investigating the
Influence of Neighborhood Context on Levels of Violence in Medellin,” by
Magdalena Cerda at http://www.psc.isr.umich.edu/events/bb-abs/10438/. In her paper, Cerda analyzed the relationship between
collective efficacy and neighborhood homicide rates and individuals’
perceptions of violent crime in their neighborhoods in Medellin, Colombia. She
came to the conclusion that collective efficacy theory may be a key factor in
lowering crime in neighborhoods in the “western world”, but does not necessarily
apply to neighborhoods in “pseudo” democracies or “developing” countries. Cerda
based her finding on measures of neighborhood structural characteristics from
census and municipal data, geo-coded police homicide records, and household
survey data from 2494 respondents in 166 neighborhoods. She found that due to
different circumstances such as paramilitary presence in the neighborhood,
collective efficacy actually has a protective effect on homicide; thus, deviant
effect on the lowering of the number of homicides.
Conclusion: Neighborhood collective efficacy
may contribute in reducing crime and violence in our “backyard,” but is not a
one-size-fits-all solution. The understanding
of collective efficacy can help shape strategies aimed at reducing a
neighborhood’s crime. But, without outside action aimed at improving such
neighborhood’s economic infrastructure anything – including criminal activity -
can become a solution to put food on a neighborhood’s table.